

Tori rushes to Brandon's room and discovers his journal filled with these symbols as well as drawings of his murderous actions to Erica and Noah. When the two leave, Deever arrives to the Breyer house and asks Tori about the symbols used after Erica and Noah's death, only for Tori to ask him to leave. After pushing Kyle to the wall for confronting him and figuring out he might be behind the recent events, he and Tori decide to have Kyle shoot him in the woods in the guise of a hunting trip. Tori and Kyle become incredibly scared and concerned for Brandon. As he dies, Brandon uses Noah's blood to make the same symbol from the diner windows. He is stopped by Brandon and uses telekinetic powers to lift and drop the truck with Noah in it to the ground, causing Noah to have his jaw torn off from his face when smashing onto the wheel. Brandon disappears again and Noah drives away in his truck in fear. Brandon then sneaks into Noah's closet with the mask and tries to take him home, only to disappear and reappear to telekinetic push Noah to his house. The police led by Chief Deputy Deever are investigating Erica's disappearance at the diner and Deever discovers a strange symbol on the glass windows. He leaves behind a flower on her laptop and goes to the diner in a mask where he pierces Erica's eye with a piece of glass, laser beams his way into the freezer, and kills her off-screen. He later goes to see Caitlyn in her bedroom and explains to her that he has discovered that he is "special" and plans to show the world that. Brandon is upset by their lie, storms out of the barn, and tears apart the family photos, declaring his hatred for his adopted parents. Tori gets him to stop only to be cut on his hand when he falls and Tori explains how he was found. When he walks to the barn's storage again, he breaks the lock chain and discovers the spaceship calling to him and hovers above it. He receives a two-day suspension, but Caitlyn's mother and diner waitress Erica wants him arrested.

During gym class when Caitlyn intentionally has Brandon hit the ground during an exercise and publicly calls him a "pervert", he crushes her hand. He is later shown to have urges for a girl in his class named Caitlyn and sneaks into her room while the family is camping. Brandon tells Kyle off and has an outburst, causing the family to leave. On his birthday at the local diner, Brandon receives a rifle as a birthday gift from his uncle Noah, only for Kyle to refuse to let him have it. While trying to mow the lawn, Brandon discovers his indestructible strength. He constantly talks in an alien language and goes to the barn where his spaceship is locked in a storage. However, as he turns 12 years old, he starts to reach puberty and begins to change. As he nears puberty, Brandon appears to be everything Tori and Kyle have ever wanted as he grows to be incredibly smart and helps around the farm, though has never bled and the couple had explained to him that he was adopted out of an agency. Their wish appears to come true when a spaceship crashes in the woods and the couple discovers a mysterious baby boy whom they name Brandon. Tori and Kyle Breyer dream of starting a family, but struggle with fertility.
